So, my friend Kirk is a staunch conservative. I both love and hate him for that, depending on the day.
Here’s a great blog post he shared today that I wanted to pass along.
Dinner and a Movie with Moby and Nancy Pelosi
Soooo last night was one of my more surreal experiences in Washington, DC. More surreal than my picture with Chloe from 24, even.
My friend Russ and I were invited by my new friend Mike Allen, White House correspondent for Time Magazine (many thanks to Deckard for the introduction!) to the Premiere of HBO’s new documentary on evangelicals and politics by Alexandra Pelosi, daughter of Speaker Nancy Pelosi at Washington’s Ritz Carlton hotel (and yes, the food was amazing too).
http://www.hbo.com/docs/programs/friends_of_god/index.html.
The room was filled with liberal Washington icons — Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Massachussetts congressman Ed Markey, TV commentator Al Hunt, MSNBC’s Chris Matthews, liberal musician Moby, about 200 other Democrats, and about 5 of us evangelicals. Since Mike knows and is loved by everyone who is anyone in Washington, and is himself an evangelical, Alexandra, and many of her guests took a great interest to our thoughts about her new film. Without hesitation, I would recommend all evangelicals see this documentary.
Alexandra is most famous for her documentary, for which she won an Emmy, showing the very human side of President Bush from the 2000 campaign called “Journeys with George”, which I understand the President himself enjoyed. So despite her being the daughter of a liberal San Francisco Speaker of the House, she has demonstrated a commitment to fairness. I anticipate there will be a lot of criticism from the evangelical community on her new movie, and I don’t think it will be entirely fair.
The film was completed just days before Ted Haggard’s (former President of the National Association of Evangelicals) tacit confession that he’d had an affair with a gay prostitute. Unfortunately for evangelicals, he serves as Alexandra’s tour guide through evangelicalism. This is especially painful during one segment where Haggard brags, very explicitly, about how great his sex life is as an evangelical. Also highlighted prominently are Joel Osteen and Jerry Falwell, as well as a number of “Christian subculture” organizations about which many of us would ask, “Does evangelicalism really need our own?” (Christian Wrestling Federation, for example).
She takes us to Osteen’s 36,000-in-weekly-attendance church service in Houston, and then on to Ted Haggard’s own megachurch in Colorado Springs, where he is giving media training to his congregation (“Don’t be weird,” he instructs them, advice which many of us would say he failed to follow himself!). We met the Cruisers for Christ (an antique car group), found a drive-through church in Richmond, and explored the Holy Land Experience in Orlando — think of it as 1st Century Disney-Jerusalem (Jesus was looking quite WASPish). We observed a children’s anti-evolution conference with Ken Ham of Answers in Genesis, saw Ron Luce rocking his Teen Mania “battlecry” youth meetings, and played Biblical mini-golf. And we can’t forget the truly-funny Christian comedian who does a great impression of Dennis Leary (sans smokes, but just as faux-angry) and the homeschooling Mennonite Tennessee family of 12 (where all the girls wear matching burqa-replicate dresses, of course).
So if you are like me, you cringed through most of that summary. Granted, most of those folks are not who I would have chosen as the spokesmen for Evangelicalism. They were probably more representative of the Pentecostal/fundamentalist strain of evangelicalism that has its own TV networks; but that IS representative of a large segment of our brothers and sisters. And much of what was said I found myself praising God for, even while those things got a few snickers from the left-leaning premiere audience. We were presented as passionate about the right to life. Ted Haggard rightly identified us as believing in the Bible and the need to be born again to be saved from God’s judgment. And we looked like the very joyful group of people that we should be, something that Alexandra took notice of.
The people who were featured in this film will absolutely feel like they were presented fairly and accurately (with the possible exception of a few cut-aways to a near-snarling Jerry Falwell). So in that sense, Alexandra Pelosi’s film is very fair, and I really believe that she wanted to present us in the best light possible.
It would only be unfair if this is characterized as representative of all of evangelicalism. Our conversation with Alexandra following the film, where she listened eagerly to our perspectives, demonstrated to me how fair-minded and serious a documentarian she really is. She agreed with many of the points made in the documentary about the double-standards that evangelicals are treated to by so-called tolerant liberals. I hope to have the chance to share with her how, specifically, there is diversity within evangelicalism, that may not have been represented in the film, through no malintent on her part. She was surprised that Russ, a very informed evangelical, didn’t know the names of most of the people in the film, and her comment to the NY Times about her experience was quite telling to me:
”I believe in the culture war,” she said. ”And you know what? If I have to take a side in the culture war I’ll take their side,” meaning the Christian conservatives. ”Because if you give me the choice of Paris Hilton or Jesus, I’ll take Jesus.”
Amen to that. This tells me that our brothers and sisters she interacted with, although some a little odd for our tastes, represented Christ in a way that brings glory to God. And we can be grateful for that.